Ahem.
As a keen reader of this blog (ha!) might expect, the HMC project came to a screeching halt not too long ago. Here are some of the problems I encountered:
1.) After a good amount of progress with my HMC, it didn't seem that important to increase the number of healthy meals I had amassed. So it stagnated at about 15 for a long time. My weight wasn't going up, OR down, so I began to become complacent.
2.) On my annual family holiday, snacking and eating "unhealthy" food was pretty much the norm. So that knocked my HMC count to negative numbers.
3.) After losing all the meals I had amassed, it felt like a real pain to start from zero, and work my way up to 10 meals again.
4.) I had unfortunately conflated losing weight/fat with the goal of the HMC project, which was to document the quantifiable effects of eating "healthy" meal by meal. As my purpose became muddled, I quickly lost interest in the experiment.
5.) I was keen on restarting the project, but as my wife became pregnant I relinquished all of our meal decisions to her. The lack of autonomy over what I could eat quickly made embarking on a new HMC stretch very difficult.
But what I've learnt so far is:
a.) Without huge changes to the composition of your meals, following the rules of the HMC can make a positive change in your health and fitness.
b.) As long as the HMC goes up over time, you will reap noticeable benefits, particularly weight/fat loss.
c.) However, if your HMC stagnates for too long, the perceived benefits will diminish fairly quickly.
All in all, I've found that the HMC is ok as a simple way to start eating healthy, particularly for people who are of the achievement-hunter/collectivist type disposition. But I personally find it rather unsustainable unless you have a clear goal; such as reaching a certain fat percentage, or reaching a HMC number. The numbers started to mean less and less to me, and subtracting my unhealthy meals from my hard earned HMC caused me undue grief and anxiety. So it's not really as adaptable as I'd like, even though tracking a number should be fairly straightforward and fuss free.
I think for the HMC to work, if you are a results or goal oriented person (such as I tend to be - at least for my physique) you have to have timeline and/or you have to set a specific target HMC to reach by then. For example, say you want to race to 100 HMC: I have no doubt that will make a significant change in your body composition and health. If you have 5 meals a day, that's only 20 days of strict dieting, maybe 25-30 days if you have a few subtractions here and there.
Or if you have a few months, and you want to get healthier: you can aim to increase your daily HMC by 1. That's 100 days of 2 clean meals and 1 cheat meal, or 3 clean meals and 2 cheat snacks. I'm sure that there will be noticeable, if not particularly impressive results by the end.
One of the problems with the HMC is that it needs to be more specific about what constitutes unhealthy eating. It has too much leeway for misinterpretation. 1 cheat meal of ice cream and apple pie could be construed as a -1 HMC, when in actual fact - after considering the portion sizes and the sugar content, the meal could easily be a -3 or more.
So in conclusion: as with any diet the most effective use of the HMC is if it is done strictly, consistently and with a clear goal HMC number in mind.
For now I shall be putting this project to rest. I will no doubt carry some of the principles I've learnt over to my continuing work on my own health and fitness. I intend to do some bodybuilding, focusing on specific goals such as cutting and bulking, and their respective nutritional requirements.
So how many meals does it take to change your body? From my experience - a HMC of 10 within a week is a good start, and hitting HMC 20 will make you feel pretty good. But for permanent and significant change, it's important to look beyond amassing numbers. It's more important to consider a mindset that makes consistency and sustainability easy, and not a chore. An active choice that is easy to passively enact, if you will.
Thanks for sticking around, and all the best for anyone who's trying to lead a healthier and more fulfilling life.
Sincerely,
Bang